A featured contribution from Leadership Perspectives: a curated forum reserved for leaders nominated by our subscribers and vetted by our Environmental Business Review Advisory Board.

MIG

Mike Campbell, Director of Environmental Analysis

Strengthening Communities through Environmental Planning and Analysis

Mike Campbell

Mike Campbell

Community Resilience Planner

Balancing Environmental Protection with Practical Development

As a municipal planner, you must first focus your review of development proposals on compliance with regulatory parameters (zoning, general plan, design guidelines) and conformance with environmental review requirements. Protection of environmental resources is often embedded in the land use and development standards of a municipality’s zoning ordinance and in the goals and policies of its general plan and design guidelines, so implementing these standards and policies through the project review process achieves a certain level of balance between environmental protection and development needs.

As an environmental consultant reviewing a proposed project, whether for a private developer or a government agency, your principal responsibility is to provide environmental clearance with maximum legal defensibility while minimizing processing time, which generally equals cost.

I carefully scope the project at the outset to develop realistic budgets and timelines and to assign adequate in-house or subconsultant staff to address each resource area (air quality/greenhouse gas emissions, biological resources, cultural resources, noise, traffic, etc.). Clear communication with the applicant, from early scoping to adoption of the final document, is always a winning strategy.

Addressing Complicated Environmental Assessments

Unforeseen circumstances can force a client to make changes that ripple through the environmental analyses throughout the document, and revisions in response to these mid-stream changes add time and cost.

The best defense is a good offense: writing specific assumptions into the proposal about changes to the project after work has begun helps avoid misunderstandings by either party. Changes imposed by decision makers at public hearings can sometimes be avoided by holding public meetings as study sessions ahead of the meetings at which the decision on the project will be made.

It is always helpful for the consultant to know a project’s funding source before starting work on the environmental document. Private developers typically have financing in place when they apply for entitlements. Public projects are often funded through Capital Improvement Plan budgets, which are subject to shifting community priorities, economic variables, and fluctuating revenues, and state and federal grants can be revoked. Maintaining clear communication with the client about funding lets you plan to complete the environmental review even if funding later becomes unavailable.

Meeting Regulatory Requirements While Advancing Sustainability

Environmental consultants have a big role to play in advancing sustainability, and sea level rise is a good example. In the San Francisco Bay Area, where I work, impacts resulting from sea level rise extend beyond city boundaries, so collaboration among neighboring cities and counties is key to resilience and adaptation.

"As an environmental consultant reviewing a proposed project, whether for a private developer or a government agency, your principal responsibility is to provide environmental clearance with maximum legal defensibility while minimizing processing time, which generally equals cost."

Senate Bill 272 requires local governments within the coastal zone or the jurisdiction of the San Francisco Bay Conservation and Development Commission to develop sea level rise resiliency plans by 2034. In response, bayside cities from San Mateo County to Marin County are forming special districts and preparing plans in conformance with SB 272.

Through collaboration and pooling of resources, these districts can implement projects that mitigate sea level rise, flooding, and coastal erosion more effectively, and promote equity through vulnerability assessments addressing the needs of the most at-risk communities. Consultants included on resilience plan teams provide expertise in assessing sea level rise impacts on the environment and local infrastructure, as well as environmental justice. Firms like mine can participate in other ways as well, such as community outreach activities and public meeting facilitation.

Preparing for Environmental Emerging Trends

As planners and business leaders, we certainly need to advocate for adaptation strategies to address threats we once considered emerging trends but that climate change has made our reality: droughts, floods, increasing storm intensity and frequency, and heat-related illnesses. But technological advances, societal change, and politics have also pushed new environmental issues and challenges to the forefront, as the growing awareness of AI’s environmental effects and the resulting pushback against data center development show.

We should focus increasingly on alternative and renewable energy, both to meet the rising electricity demands this technology creates and to shift away from fossil fuel dependency. Water supply and quality have always been of great interest to me as an environmental planner, and they will become more critical as climate change effects are realized and population growth outstrips available supplies.

These will require improved technologies and the political will to facilitate more intensive water conservation and recycling. I also find it genuinely concerning that our natural environment is increasingly threatened by federal government actions, including the spread of misinformation and funding cuts to the agencies established to protect our natural resources, air and water quality, open spaces, and public health.

Building Careers in Environmental Planning and Analysis

As we take on existing and new challenges, it is important to engage with our local communities, because as professional planners and stewards of the environment, we act on their behalf. The strength of our communities to resolve problems and make improvements lies with the participation of as many people as possible, and with the guidance of professional planners and environmental analysts familiar with the issues. 

Participating in volunteer activities and neighborhood organization meetings, and serving on boards and commissions, is a good way to familiarize yourself with the community’s perspective. A team leader is first and foremost a team player, so utilize and demonstrate trust in your team members’ strengths.

It is important to remember that good customer service also includes providing good internal service for team members and co-workers. To be an effective leader, be a good “people person” by being accessible and forming positive working relationships with community members, your team members, and clients alike.

The articles from these contributors are based on their personal expertise and viewpoints, and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of their employers or affiliated organizations.